And The Defense Wins

Pdf Version by DRI

Constantine J. Themelis, Kamil Ismail, Paul Rouhana, and Michael Correnti


DRI members Constantine J. Themelis and Kamil Ismail of Goodell, Devries, Leech & Dann, LLP, Paul Rouhana of the Law Offices of Seigel, Tully, Rouhana & Tully, LLC and Michael Correnti of McDonald Toole Wiggins, P.A., representing Cluck-U Corporation, a restaurant franchise headquartered in Maryland and owned by Jean-Pierre Haddad, prevailed on all claims related to a Franchise Agreement that it entered into with a North Port, Florida franchisee owned and operated by Anthony L. Tartaglia.

In Cluck-U Chicken, Inc. v. Cluck-U Corporation, et al., pending before Magistrate Mark A. Pizzo in the Middle District of Florida, Tampa Division, the Florida franchisee asserted various claims against Cluck-U Corporation and Mr. Haddad for fraud, violations of Florida’s Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act, and breach of the Franchise Agreement. Cluck-U Corporation denied all claims in their entirety and asserted breach of contract claims against the Florida franchisee for closing the Cluck-U store in 2015 and opening a competing restaurant in the same location.

During the four-day jury trial, Cluck-U Corporation vigorously defended against the Florida franchisee’s allegations. At the close of all evidence, and before closing arguments were made, the court granted Cluck-U Corporation’s Rule 50 motion and entered judgment as a matter of law for all claims asserted by the Florida franchisee against Cluck-U Corporation and Mr. Haddad. More specifically, the court determined that the Florida franchisee had failed to come forward with any evidence to support their allegations against Cluck-U Corporation. As a result, the jury was instructed to disregard all of the Florida franchisee’s claims, and the jury was asked to only deliberate on Cluck-U Corporation’s claims for breach of contract against the Florida franchisee. After a short deliberation, the jury came back with a unanimous verdict in favor of Cluck-U Corporation. The jury found that the Florida franchisee had breached the Franchise Agreement and Cluck-U Corporation was awarded liquidated damages as a result of the Florida franchisee’s breach.

Cluck-U Corporation, known as Cluck-U nationally and Clucksters internationally, currently has 16 stores throughout the United States and two international stores in Lebanon.
To learn more about DRI, an international membership organization of attorneys defending the interests of business and individuals in civil litigation, visit dri.org.